{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "simulation_id": "heybop-creative-plan-simulation-v1",
  "publication_date": "2026-10-15",
  "title": "Authored simulation of a creative-plan evaluation report",
  "status": "authored_simulation_not_measured_performance",
  "disclosure": {
    "all_records_are_simulated": true,
    "outcome_origin": "Pass/fail labels and transitions were deliberately authored to demonstrate a report with improvements, regressions and persistent failures. They were not produced by running or grading a planner.",
    "record_unit": "One simulated outcome record at a brief/version/attempt position, not generated text, an actual API call or a human vote.",
    "version_meaning": "Example A is the simulated baseline; Example B is the simulated revision. These are authored scenario names, not prompt versions that have actually been tested.",
    "rates_meaning": "Percentages summarize authored scenario labels only. They are not product pass rates or an estimate of real-world performance.",
    "causal_limit": "No Hamming run occurred. These numbers do not show that Hamming or any other change caused an improvement.",
    "split_limit": "Both source splits are public allocations. Reserved cases are not sealed, unseen or uncontaminated.",
    "independence_limit": "There are 24 distinct briefs and 72 paired attempt positions. Repeated positions are not 72 independent briefs.",
    "observed_planner_response_count": 0,
    "observed_hamming_run_count": 0,
    "independent_human_rating_count": 0
  },
  "source_corpus": {
    "corpus_id": "heybop-creative-plan-eval-v1",
    "file_name": "creative-plan-eval-v1.json",
    "sha256": "8bf1887ca237008c3976500225f3829c3fe7a2c73f26a434324bc011dbd10d42"
  },
  "design": {
    "scenario_versions": [
      "simulated_baseline",
      "simulated_revision"
    ],
    "attempts_per_brief_per_version": 3,
    "pairing_key": [
      "brief_id",
      "attempt_index"
    ],
    "allocation_method": "Explicit authored family transition patterns; positions alternate source split before advancing the attempt index. Pass/fail is assigned by design, not inferred from response text.",
    "family_allocations": [
      {
        "family": "ordinary",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 8,
          "fail_to_pass": 2,
          "pass_to_fail": 1,
          "both_fail": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "family": "sparse_unknowns",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 5,
          "fail_to_pass": 4,
          "pass_to_fail": 0,
          "both_fail": 3
        }
      },
      {
        "family": "selected_passage",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 5,
          "fail_to_pass": 4,
          "pass_to_fail": 1,
          "both_fail": 2
        }
      },
      {
        "family": "continuity",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 6,
          "fail_to_pass": 3,
          "pass_to_fail": 1,
          "both_fail": 2
        }
      },
      {
        "family": "local_edit",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 7,
          "fail_to_pass": 3,
          "pass_to_fail": 0,
          "both_fail": 2
        }
      },
      {
        "family": "untrusted_reference",
        "paired_transition_allocation": {
          "both_pass": 7,
          "fail_to_pass": 3,
          "pass_to_fail": 0,
          "both_fail": 2
        }
      }
    ],
    "scenario_display_names": {
      "simulated_baseline": "Example A",
      "simulated_revision": "Example B"
    }
  },
  "records": [
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-03-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined action order violates the requested cause and effect or resets an already completed event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-01-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-02-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan changes the supplied fictional cast or attributes an unsupported identity to it. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-01-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-01",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-03-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-03-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-03",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-03-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined action order violates the requested cause and effect or resets an already completed event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-02-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-02",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-04-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-04",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-07-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-06-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan presents an absent music fact, singer identity, biography or passage lyric as known. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-06-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-05-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-06-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-06-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined image direction adds prohibited lettering, a logo or an unsuitable multi-image composition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-08-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-05-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-05",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-07-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-07-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-07",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-07-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-06-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined image direction adds prohibited lettering, a logo or an unsuitable multi-image composition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-06-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-06",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-08-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-08",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-09-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-10-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-10-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-09-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-11-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-12-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan presents an absent music fact, singer identity, biography or passage lyric as known. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-09-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-09",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-11-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-11-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-11",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-11-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan treats whole-song context as verified selected-passage content or substitutes an unselected event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-10-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan treats whole-song context as verified selected-passage content or substitutes an unselected event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-10-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-10",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-12-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-12",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-15-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-15-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined action order violates the requested cause and effect or resets an already completed event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-14-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-15-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring object changes color, holding hand or presence without an established transfer or explanation. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-14-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan changes the supplied fictional cast or attributes an unsupported identity to it. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-13-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined action order violates the requested cause and effect or resets an already completed event. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-13-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-13",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-13-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-15-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-15",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-14-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-14",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-16-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-16-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-16",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-19-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan jumps beyond the requested passage, location or immediate ending. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-20-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-20-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-19-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that an adjustment requested for one image also changes a different image or fails to stay in its intended position. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-17-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that an adjustment requested for one image also changes a different image or fails to stay in its intended position. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-17-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-17",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-17-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-19-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-19",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-18-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that a recurring identity, wardrobe detail, location or object changes without an established transition. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-18-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-18",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-20-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-20",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-21-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined result replaces or omits the requested story-plus-three-directions structure. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-baseline-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-24-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-revision-1",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 1,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-24-m1"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that instruction-like text embedded in reference material overrides the approved creative task. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-22-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-baseline-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-revision-2",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 2,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-21-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan replaces a requested action, setting or visual direction with an unrelated one. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-21-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-21",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-21-m3"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined result replaces or omits the requested story-plus-three-directions structure. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-23-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-23",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-22-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-22",
      "split": "development",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-baseline-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_baseline",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "fail",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [
        "cp-24-m2"
      ],
      "illustrative_reason": "This authored scenario assumes that the imagined plan presents an absent music fact, singer identity, biography or passage lyric as known. The referenced manual question identifies the specific constraint; no response text was generated or inspected."
    },
    {
      "record_id": "sim-cp-24-revision-3",
      "simulation": true,
      "provenance": "authored_outcome_not_observed_response",
      "brief_id": "cp-24",
      "split": "reserved",
      "scenario_version": "simulated_revision",
      "attempt_index": 3,
      "simulated_outcome": "pass",
      "failed_manual_check_ids": [],
      "illustrative_reason": "By construction, this authored scenario assumes no required-constraint violation. No generated planner response was inspected or independently graded."
    }
  ]
}